Butcher haig. Was Douglas Haig Really “The Butcher of the Somme”? 2019-01-26

Butcher haig Rating: 9,2/10 889 reviews

Haig: Butcher of the Somme?

butcher haig

The falsification of his diary seems equally inept, given the frequency with which its contents are held against the author's competence, integrity and humanity, not least by Winter himself. The two corps were supposed to meet at but I Corps under Haig were stopped at , leaving a large gap between the two corps. John Terraine wrote: It is important, when we feel our emotions rightly swelling over the losses of 1914—18, to remember that in 1939—45 the world losses were probably over four times as many. He still pursued with that tactic. He repeated the mistakes opposite of what was said organized. Haig was required to dismiss Charteris. There was also argument over the placement of the reserve, Haking with the and inexperienced divisions , which Haig wanted close to the front.

Next

General Haig: Butcher or War Winner? Essay Example

butcher haig

Was Haig the right man for the job? The machine gun was a fairly new and popular invention, but Haig seemed to use them unwillingly. Or was he just doing his job and was there any misunderstanding in the battle? The failure of the Nivelle Offensive in April 1917 which Haig had been required to support with a British offensive by the and at Arras and the subsequent French mutiny and political crisis, discredited Lloyd George's plans for Anglo-French co-operation for the time being. After this, the British troops would walk across no-mans land unopposed and take the German trenches. Many people believed that the battle symbolised all the horrors of warfare in World War One. As a consequence the army was poorly positioned to adapt quickly. Either would have been better than brainlessly sending men to their deaths. Haig was asked by Clive Wigram one of the King's press staff to smooth relations between French and Kitchener.

Next

Does General Haig deserve the title Butcher of the Somme?

butcher haig

It is the job of the more important members of the army to either help him or move in a different general. It may have looked like a victory for the Allies but the reality was quite different, as subsequent operations against the line in 1917 would show. The battle lasted for five months and the allies lost 620,000 men most of them were British. Bourne considered this to be too harsh. This is because Haig sent thousands of men to their deaths continuously after his war efforts seemed not to be working.

Next

General Douglas Haig Butcher or Hero

butcher haig

To End All Wars: A Story of Loyalty and Rebellion, 1914—1918. A Canadian brigade took part in an action at. The attack was less successful than Neuve Chapelle as the forty-minute bombardment only 516 field guns and 121 heavy guns was over a wider front and against stronger defences; Haig was still focussed on winning a decisive victory by capturing key ground, rather than amassing firepower to inflict maximum damage on the Germans. D This list is ; you can help by. A became more powerful and businesses grew all over Europe and the U. This reason is how he was not informed well.

Next

Did General Haig deserve to be the Butcher of the Somme?

butcher haig

In some ways these consequences were opposed by better and brighter things, but not forgotten. Travers suggests that Haig had written off both Fifth Army and the link with the French at this point, that he called Henry Wilson over to France to discuss a retreat on the Channel Ports, and that he wanted the 20 French divisions at Amiens not to maintain the link with the French but to cover the British retreat or perhaps to counterattack. On the first day of July 1916, the battle of the Somme started and British troops went over the top. His plan did not involve any soldier experience based knowledge. To say that Haig was the hero of the victory at the Somme, although the opinion of the people of the time, must now be looked back on with great scepticism. Joffre was not pleased and called another conference 11 July to urge a British attack on Loos.


Next

Haig: Butcher of the Somme?

butcher haig

Of the 3,080 men sentenced to death in all theatres, 346 were executed, 266 77% were for desertion, 37 for murder who would probably have been hanged under civilian law at the time and 18 for cowardice. Battle began 25 September after Haig ordered the release of he had an aide, Alan Fletcher, light a cigarette to test the wind. Aldershot in the Great War: The Home of the British Army. He was not an aristocrat by birth, or landed gentry. This might be supporting the point that he was just doing his job and he made a great success in the war.

Next

Was Douglas Haig Really “The Butcher of the Somme”?

butcher haig

Haig belonged to the lower officer corps of the pre-war army, yet he progressed along with other commanders of the Edwardian era from battalion, brigade, division and corps command, to the army group and commanders-in-chief of the First World War. Overall, I think they both sum up views of people. He was present at the 8 April , after which he criticised Kitchener for launching a frontal attack without taking the Dervishes in flank as well. Haig impressed the Chief Instructor, Lt-Col G. Haig and Robertson hoped that this would be the start of a new and more professional management of the war.

Next

Does General Haig deserve the reputation as the 'Butcher of the Somme?

butcher haig

In the first four hours, 12 battalions made up of 10,000 men suffered a staggering 8,000 casualties — and the number of British casualties at the end of the main attack stood at over a quarter of a million 285,107. Especially on the first day of the battle, which lost a massive number of casualties in the war history? Haig's death mask, Edinburgh Castle Lloyd George pulled fewer punches in his War Memoirs, published in 1936 when Haig was dead and Lloyd George no longer a major political player. He was described in later accounts to be a great leader and one of the reasons the British did win. Of those that did explode, too many were shrapnel shells rather than high explosive, which made little impression on barbed wire and reinforced dug outs. The question remains however would the extra six weeks to prepare made a difference? At around 9 pm he decided to continue the attack on Bourlon Wood, a decision which has been much criticised but which made good military sense at the time and was supported by Byng, although the political need for a clear victory may also have been a factor. The introduction is the weakest area and could have included a line of argument.


Next

Field Marshal Haig: “Hero or Butcher of the Somme”

butcher haig

Haig's records of his time supervising artillery exercises show little interest in technical matters aim, range, accuracy etc. The barbed wire has never been so well cut, not the artillery preparation so thorough. A man who gained his ends by trickery of a kind that was not merely immoral but criminal. Haig was making similar complaints about Lloyd George, whom he privately compared to the Germans accusing the Allies of atrocities, of which they were guilty. If this occurred, a decisive victory would be much more difficult to obtain. W e can say that both so urces are about Haig, source D clearly mentions Haig and the Somme, and source E indirectly criticizes Haig. His outdated tactics led to the war being even more prolonged and unintentionally prevented a victory over the Germans.

Next